After reading a interesting analysis of a recent Newsweek article on race at Princeton yesterday at
Reconciliation Blog, I couldn't help but feel pessimistic about the complexity and ambiguity of race relations in America.
On top of that, I'm feeling BURNT OUT. In the two years that I have been here, I’ve seen our Organization of Latin American Students organization fall apart, our Student Senate position for cultural awareness disappear, our “cultural awareness week” collapse to one day, and the Black Student Organization hover on extinction at least 3 times. I’ve been forced to ask some hard questions about the relevancy of these groups and “awareness." The campus is no more diverse than when I arrived: we still only have 2 Hispanic professors and 1 African American faculty member.
Our forum on race this year took an astonishing turn with some or our black students proudly claimed that they would never take any scholarship money based on their racial/cultural background--- in response to a white student’s complaint that she felt “racism” because she did not have access to the same types of federal funds that minority students might have (never mind she has a full golf scholarship --- but that’s because she worked hard, right?). I really didn’t know what to do with that conversation. The black students felt proud because they challenged a stereotype; I felt sad because I tend to think the real problem is the assumption that we all start at the same place and if we “work hard” then we will get what we deserve. White privilege in action.
Then, there are the conversations that I have almost daily with my staff. They are supportive to an extent but still resist policies and strategies that address openly the issue of race on our campus with all the convenient dismissals: it’s not really that bad, “they” just need to find their place here, the world is just broken: we are always going to be this problem so why try. The result is effectively a policy of silence and assimilation. Every year some brave souls try to start the conversation again, but after a few meetings, it dies. Meanwhile, it gets harder and harder for advocates of diversity to stay here.
I wish that white people would understand that not talking about it is what upholds the status quo and contributes to the every-day feelings of isolation, uneasiness, and the endlessly exhausting process of translation for minority students. There is no sense of safety; there is no sense that they can really say what they think and feel, that their experience will be received. The message our university communicates? It is not acceptable, maybe even “un-Christian” to acknowledge difference. Difference destroys unity. Or rather, acknowledgement of difference destroys the veneer of safety and stability that has been cultivated around the illusion of shared identity.
I’m tired of these conversations too. I’m tired of talking about “diversity” or the Christianized version of “reconciliation.” Don’t get me wrong – I believe strongly in the power of reconciliation, but would I rather have 1) a university that talks about reconciliation so that it doesn’t have to actually make any structural changes and can absolve itself of some guilt while looking a little less white or 2) a university where reconciliation isn’t even part of the vocabulary and everyone assumes that if they can just be a “nice Christian community” that is enough. The former is hypocritical and the latter is naïve. Both, in my experience, are difficult places to work.
And in the end, it’s the students who suffer year after year. They are the one’s desperately waiting, sometimes not even aware that they are waiting. As a community, if we are really going to make this reconciliation thing work, we are going to have to learn how to hold pain, how to hold anger, how to acknowledge guilt, and how to claim an identity of grace, love and forgiveness over all other identities – while still recognizing and celebrating our unique differences. This is the university, the church, the nation, the world, I envision. But how to cultivate this?